Ally is mortified when her friends throw her a surprise birthday party. A man with a foot fetish refuses to use insanity as a defense.
- Calista Flockhart as Ally McBeal
- Courtney Thorne-Smith as Georgia Thomas
- Greg Germann as Richard Fish
- Lisa Nicole Carson as Renée Raddick
- Jane Krakowski as Elaine Vassal
- with Peter MacNicol as John Cage
- and Gil Bellows as Billy Thomas
- Jesse L. Martin as Dr. Greg Butters
- Harriet Sansom Harris as Cheryl Bonner
- Barry Miller as Mark Henderson
- Vonda Shepard as Herself
- Alaina Reed Hall as Judge Elizabeth Witt
Greg Butters escorts Ally up the steps to her apartment. Greg pulls Ally close and gives her a kiss. She invites him upstairs, but he declines, asking for a rain check. When Ally enters the apartment, she grabs hold of the inflatable doll and yanks it into her bedroom. The following morning, Ally laments to Renee that she is about to turn twenty-eight. The conversation is interrupted by a telephone call, which Renee answers. Ally's ears perk up when Renee mentions the name Mark Henderson. Later, when Ally enters the conference room, she informs her colleagues that Renee was assigned to prosecute the case.
In court, Renee questions Cheryl Bonner, who describes how Henderson entered her apartment in the wee hours of the morning and began tickling her foot as she slept. When Bonner awoke, she began screaming and dialed the police. On cross-examination, Ally notes that Henderson and Bonner were dating at the time, and that Henderson found that the door to her apartment was, in fact, unlocked. Later, Ally and Renee discuss the case. Ally grabs one of Reneeıs feet, and removing her shoe, gives her a massage (in an attempt to talk her into a plea bargain). Cage and Fish listen from the doorway as Renee's moans of pleasure reach almost orgasmic proportions. But an agreement is not reached, and the trial continues. Henderson explains that his third date with Bonner went very well. When she revealed her love for foot massages, which she described as erotic, Henderson took it upon himself to surprise her. He describes in loving detail how he entered the apartment and caressed Bonner's foot. Later, Ally is taken aback when Henderson refuses to allow her to submit an insanity plea.
Elaine invites Greg to sing at Ally's upcoming surprise birthday party. During a rehearsal at the bar, Greg sings a number that attracts the attention of every woman within earshot. He is blessed with a dreamy, erotic voice.
Ally invites Henderson and Bonner to the bar, hoping they can work out their differences outside of court. Suddenly, a spotlight hits Ally, and Vonda dedicates a song to her, Peggy Lee's I am a Woman. Ally is mortified. Elaine then picks up the lyrics, strutting like a sexy siren. The spotlight then pans to Renee, who also joins in. A short time later, after the singing subsides, Ally meets with Cheryl, Henderson and Cage. But the scheme does not go well, and Cheryl labels Henderson as sick. Ally pulls Cheryl aside for a private talk. Cheryl explains that, for once in her life, she thought she had met Mr. Right. She was mortified when she awoke and discovered him tickling her foot. Henderson overhears part of the conversation and apologizes for his behavior. Shortly thereafter, the spotlight returns to Vonda, who says there's one last gift for the birthday girl. Greg's sexy voice overwhelms every woman in the audience. Suddenly inspired, Renee belts out a companion piece to Greg's song. The pair make a steamy duo... causing Ally to grow enormously jealous.
Back at the apartment, Renee insists she has no interest in dating Greg. Their discussion is interrupted when Greg drops by for a visit. He takes Ally's hand and informs her that he has accepted a new job at a Chicago hospital (which explains why he was reluctant to begin a sexual relationship). He believes that, had things worked out differently, he could very easily have fallen in love with her. Ally remains stoic, pretending she is not hurt. But Renee, who eavesdropped on the conversation, is moved to tears.
The next morning, Ally awakens in an upbeat mood... only to discover sheıs lying to herself. She grabs hold of the inflatable doll and sits on it, causing the doll to explode. Later, in court, Ally presents her closing argument in the Henderson case. She maintains that the issue isn't feet, it's about entering a personıs dwelling without being invited inside. She blames Hendersonıs action not on insanity, but on loneliness. Instead of being passive, and allowing his personal life to slip by, Henderson, Ally believes, took control of his destiny. And though she admits her client was too assertive, she also states that he is not a criminal.
Greg approaches Ally in the court corridor. He tells her that since he won't be leaving town for another two weeks, he sees no reason why they cannot continue seeing each other. But Ally maintains she is not a 'que sera' kind of girl. Greg gives her a kiss on the cheek before he leaves. When Ally returns to the office, the staff surprises her with a birthday party. The group breaks into song, causing Ally to snap at them. A policeman-stripper then enters and begins to bump and grind his hips. Everyone, including Ally, leaves the room. But Elaine remains behind and enjoys the performance.
The jury finds Henderson not guilty. Afterward, he and Cheryl decide to meet for coffee.