Ally tries the case of a throuple wishing to make it legal. Elaine goes all in on the office Christmas party, while Fish's relationship with Whipper takes a turn.
- Calista Flockhart as Ally McBeal
- Courtney Thorne-Smith as Georgia Thomas
- Greg Germann as Richard Fish
- Lisa Nicole Carson as Renée Raddick
- Jane Krakowski as Elaine Vassal
- and Gil Bellows as Billy Thomas
Special Appearance By
- Eric Pierpoint as James Horton
- Katie Mitchell as Patti Horton
- Amanda Carlin as Mindy Horton
- Vonda Shepard as Herself
As Elaine recruits singers for the firm's musical Christmas party, Fish asks Ally to take the case of James, Mindy and Pattie Horton, who would like to be a legally-married threesome. Ally is uncomfortable with the idea...and so is Whipper, who nonetheless agrees to hear the Hortons' testimony.
Fish rehearses "I Love You More Today Than Yesterday" for the Christmas party. Elaine tells him Whipper would rather have a ring than a song. Back in court, James Horton testifies that his marriage to Mindy was becoming dull until he met Pattie...then his new love helped revive his relationship with Mindy as well. The next day, Mindy says that taking Pattie into their home eliminated the secrecy of James' double life...and that it's nice to have a second mother around for the kids. Later, Georgia tells Billy that the Hortons have made her realize that Billy, too, has been more open and intimate since Ally came back into the picture. Billy denies this, but knows it's true. Cage tells Ally that James' bringing Pattie home reminds him of when his parents brought home his new baby brother (at the time, Cage was 13 months old). Cage felt it was an invasion at first, but grew to love the new baby. Ally says no one can remember things from when they were 13 months old.
As Elaine rehearses her "Ikette"-style backup singers, Billy tells Ally what Georgia said about their relationship. Ally says she never wanted to break up Billy and Georgia's marriage...but doesn't want to be the best thing that ever happened to it, either. That night, Whipper tells Fish she is going home alone. Fish tells her people should stop taking stock of their lives at Christmas; it only leads to misery. He also asks whether marriage is really all that important. She says it must be, to scare him so much.
The next day, in court, Pattie testifies that she never expected to be in a polygamous relationship...but it makes having both a career and kids much easier. Later, Fish asks Cage what to do about Whipper, but Cage is still preoccupied with his growing attraction to Ally. Finally, Georgia confronts Billy and Ally. She is angry that Ally makes Billy a better person, angry that Billy's friendship with Ally makes Billy and Georgia's marriage stronger...and angry that she likes Ally. Ally ducks out, saying the issue is between Georgia and Billy. Back in court, the opposing counsel argues that marriage, a once sacred institution, is becoming trivialized today. Cage says it is not trivial to protect and honor a solid, loving home like the Hortons'. That night, Whipper visits the Hortons' home and sees more stability there than she had in either of her two marriages.
The next day, Georgia finally gets Billy to understand that his intimacies with Ally represent less than total fidelity to Georgia. Cage steels himself to ask Ally out and, although he goes into the conversation with an open fly, extends his invitation. Ally turns him down, saying she cannot date her boss. Then the Christmas party starts. As Elaine sings with her "Ikettes," Fish is paged with the Horton verdict. Whipper rules that although the Hortons do have a successful relationship, the three-way marriage cannot be supported legally. Later, Fish picks Whipper up for the party and admits to her he is afraid of marriage. He says he loves her, but doesn't want to turn out like his own bickering parents. Back at the party, Vonda and Renee sing a duet. Ally finds Cage alone in his office. He asks how old she was at her first memory. She says 15 months...and that she will go out with him after all. This time, though, he declines. Down in the bar, Fish sings as the others dance. Up in the office, Ally and Cage share memories of Santa over a bottle of wine. Then they share a slow dance...as the party winds down downstairs.
- more today than yesterday (cover) | GREG GERMANN
- i saw mommy kissing santa clause (cover) | JANE KRAKOWSKI
- let's get it on | MARVIN GAYE
- santa claus is coming to town (cover) | LISA NICOLE CARSON & SHEPARD
- please come home for christmas (cover) | VONDA SHEPARD